Perspective & Witness: Asking How We Let It Happen

Image of a rubber duck with the word How? behind it

The Question That Stayed With Me

I don’t remember every detail of my first reading of The Diary of Anne Frank. But I remember the question it left me with. I could not understand how society allowed a young girl—and millions of others—to be persecuted, stripped of their rights, and murdered because of who they were.

The Holocaust was not a distant event in a textbook. I was trying to understand how human beings could do these things to one another. Wondered how so many others could allow it to happen. How does a society reach the point where cruelty becomes policy, neighbors become targets, and people accept or ignore suffering?

I didn’t have the answers then. I still don’t have all of them. But I have spent much of my life returning to that question.

Learning to Question

I grew up in a Republican household. At some point, I began voting for Democrats while still thinking of myself as a Republican. I can’t identify the exact moment my views changed. Perhaps there wasn’t one. My perspective developed as I questioned what I heard, considered what I saw, and tried to reconcile political positions with my understanding of right and wrong.

Later, I became a Spiritualist. My beliefs gave me a framework for thinking about personal responsibility and the connections between people. They also reinforced the importance of continuing to learn. I didn’t have to accept an idea simply because someone in authority presented it as truth.

I needed to ask questions, listen to people whose experiences differed from mine, and reconsider my beliefs when necessary. That approach doesn’t guarantee I’ll always reach the right conclusion. It does keep me examining the world rather than surrendering my judgment to someone else.

This matters when we confront injustice. People often explain events according to where they stand, what they fear, and what they stand to gain. They also decide whose suffering deserves their concern. Understanding these influences doesn’t excuse cruelty. It helps us recognize how people justify actions that should trouble them.

Recognizing Patterns

Over the years, I have returned to questions about the treatment of Palestinians, the war in Ukraine, the history of Korea, and the treatment of Native Americans. I have also questioned the ways power protects itself and the people who benefit from it.

These histories are different. Their causes, circumstances, and consequences deserve examination on their own terms. We don’t honor history by pretending every injustice is the same.

But we should ask difficult questions across these histories. Who has power? Who bears the cost? Whose suffering receives attention, and whose becomes an inconvenience? What happens when people accept an official explanation without examining the lives behind it?

Sometimes, people know about suffering and still find reasons to look away. They may feel powerless, fear speaking out, or believe the problem is too complicated. They may convince themselves that someone else will intervene. Others actively support the harm because they believe the people suffering deserve it.

These responses are not interchangeable. Fear, helplessness, indifference, and deliberate cruelty are different things. Yet each can help injustice continue, even when people can see the harm.

What History Looks Like From the Ground

I find myself thinking about these questions even while watching historical dramas. Programs such as Dr. Quinn, Medicine Woman, *M*A*S*H*, and Outlander aren’t documentaries. Political decisions may look abstract from a distance, but they are never abstract to the people who must live with them.

The stories on screen make me consider lives shaped by laws, war, class, and authority. Scotland’s history, in particular, has led me to think about women’s limited choices, their lack of bodily autonomy, and the suffering ordinary people endured.

A question runs through many of these histories: What happens when one group decides it has the right to determine how another group will live?

We see it when governments deny people their rights, when societies treat some lives as less valuable than others, and when women cannot make decisions about their own bodies or futures. We see it when war displaces families and communities bear the consequences of decisions made by people with power.

These circumstances are not identical. But they raise questions about dignity and responsibility. Who gets to decide? Whose voices count? Who must sacrifice, and who decides that sacrifice is necessary?

I struggle with the distance between those who exercise power and those who live with its consequences. Making a decision from a position of security is one thing. Losing your home, facing restrictions on your body, watching your community suffer, or fearing that someone else controls your future is another.

The Limits of Attention

For years, I have written about politics, Spiritualism, accountability, and the questions that trouble me. My blog has become a record of what caught my attention, what I questioned, and how my thinking developed.

Some posts respond to particular events. Others examine a principle or challenge an assumption. Together, they reflect my ongoing effort to understand the world I inhabit.

I don’t imagine that writing a blog changes every mind or stops every injustice. I cannot investigate every story, follow every development, or give every worthy cause the attention it deserves. Even when the desire to help feels limitless, one person’s time and energy are not.

That reality has become especially clear as caring for Mom has consumed more of my time and energy. I don’t follow the news as closely as I once did. It is frustrating to know I’ve missed things, and I feel the discomfort of that absence. I don’t want my immediate responsibilities to make me stop noticing the suffering of others. The last thing I want is to become one of the people who look away.

My concern isn’t simply that I know less about current events. I worry about what that absence might mean. If I am no longer paying attention, am I turning away from the very questions that have shaped my life?

Yet I also know that my years of writing still exist. The questions I asked, the events I examined, and the perspective I recorded haven’t disappeared because I cannot keep up with every headline today.

I am still trying to understand the difference between looking away because I no longer care and stepping back because I cannot do everything. They are not the same, even if the outward result can look similar.

Perhaps bearing witness means recognizing both responsibility and limits. I can pay attention when I am able. Questioning what I am told, listen to experiences beyond my own, and acknowledge what I get wrong. I can leave a record of what I saw and understood. I can also recognize when I need to step back without deciding that stepping back means I no longer care.

Witness does not require knowing everything. It requires honesty about what we know, what we do not know, and what we are willing to acknowledge.

The Question Beneath It All

My Spiritualist beliefs bring me back to a question I have asked in different ways throughout my life. If I recognize the same divine reality in myself and in you, how can we justify harming one another?

For me, this belief speaks to our connection and our responsibility toward each other. It doesn’t mean we must agree, erase our differences, or excuse harmful behavior. It asks us to consider the value of another person’s life, even when their experiences and beliefs differ from our own.

I don’t ask because I believe the answer is simple. The contradiction deserves our attention.

I cannot promise that I will always know what to do when confronted with injustice. My life and responsibilities make it difficult to have the energy to respond or the influence to change an outcome. But I can continue asking questions, listening, learning, and writing about what I see.

A Record of Having Asked

Perhaps that is what my blog has been all along: an effort to develop perspective and bear witness. It isn’t a claim that I understand every event or have always been right. It is a record of someone trying to pay attention and make sense of the times in which she lives.

I began with a young girl’s diary and a question I could not answer. Everything I have learned since has complicated that question, but it hasn’t made it less important.

I still struggle to understand how societies allow injustice to happen. I still wonder how people come to accept the suffering of others and why the same questions about power and human dignity keep returning.

Complete answers may never come. I cannot stop every injustice or give every suffering person my attention. But I can keep asking what responsibility we bear, what we might do differently, and how to recognize the warning signs when they appear.

And I can leave a record of having asked.

Loading

One response to “Perspective & Witness: Asking How We Let It Happen”

  1. Jenny Avatar

    🫂🫂🫂

Image of Rev. Colleen Irwin sitting at a table with a selection of metaphsyical tools on the table.

Work With Colleen Irwin

Whether you are seeking clarity, validation, healing, or deeper spiritual growth, I offer readings, mentoring, and transformative experiences designed to help you move forward with confidence. Explore private sessions, upcoming classes, and events created to support your journey.

Image of Guided by Spirit Book by Rev. Colleen Irwin.

Guided by Spirit

  • Build Psychic & Mediumship Skills
  • Workbook for Students & Facilitators
  • How to create your own circle